American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. 401(k) and pension plans

American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I., Madison, WI. EIN 39-0273710. Annual reports 2009–2024. Also filed as American Family Mutual Insurance Company.

American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. has 2 active retirement plans on file. The largest is the American Family 401(k) Plan, with 16,692 participants and $2.2 billion in assets in 2024. Empower has been its recordkeeper since 2022.

Active plans: 2
Participants: 32,877
Plan assets: $3.4 billion
401(k) recordkeeper: Empower
Plans on file: 3
Industry: Finance and insurance

All 3 plans

Active plans first

American Family 401(k) Plan

401(k)Active

Active. The plan filed its annual report for the 2024 plan year.

Plan number: 002Employer EIN 39-0273710
Participants (2024): 16,692
Net assets (2024): $2.2 billion
Recordkeeper: EmpowerEarlier: Alight (2010–2019)
Plan administrator: American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.
6000 American Parkway
Madison, WI 53783
(608) 242-4100As filed for 2024
In effect since: January 1, 1973

Plans merged into this one: NGM Insurance Company 401(k) Retirement Plan (2020); Homesite Group Incorporated 401(k) Plan (2020); PGC 401(k) Plan (2020).

Earlier sponsor: American Family Mutual Insurance Company (2009–2016).

Earlier plan names: American Family 401K Plan.

Year by year, 2009 to 2024

Plan year	Participants	Net assets	Recordkeeper
2024	16,692	$2.2 billion	Empower
2023	17,472	$2.0 billion	Empower
2022	18,644	$1.7 billion	Empower
2021	18,375	$2.1 billion	not listed
2020	15,448	$1.9 billion	not listed
2019	12,201	$1.4 billion	Alight
2018	10,628	$1.1 billion	Alight
2017	10,955	$1.2 billion	Alight
2016	10,220	$1.1 billion	Alight
2015	9,649	$984 million	Alight
2014	9,350	$994 million	Alight
2013	9,086	$940 million	Alight
2012	9,189	$805 million	Alight
2011	9,386	$756 million	Alight
2010	9,278	$752 million	Alight
2009	9,283	$657 million	not listed

American Family Pension Plan

Cash balance pensionActive

Active. The plan filed its annual report for the 2024 plan year.

Plan number: 001Employer EIN 39-0273710
Participants (2024): 16,185
Net assets (2024): $1.3 billion
Administered by: Alight2023
Plan administrator: Retirement Plans Administrative Committee
6000 American Parkway
Madison, WI 53783
(608) 249-2111As filed for 2024
In effect since: January 1, 1949

Plans merged into this one: Retirement Plan for District Managers of American Family Mutual Insurance Company (2015); The NGM Insurance Co. Pension Share Account (2020).

Earlier sponsor: American Family Mutual Insurance Company (2009–2016).

Earlier plan names: Retirement Plan for Employees of American Family Insurance Group; Retirement Plan for Employees of American Family Mutual Insurance Company.

Year by year, 2009 to 2024

Plan year	Participants	Net assets	Recordkeeper
2024	16,185	$1.3 billion	not listed
2023	16,085	$1.3 billion	Alight
2022	15,947	$1.2 billion	not listed
2021	15,537	$1.9 billion	not listed
2020	16,551	$1.9 billion	not listed
2019	11,882	$1.6 billion	not listed
2018	10,704	$1.4 billion	not listed
2017	10,183	$1.5 billion	not listed
2016	9,509	$923 million	not listed
2015	9,237	$845 million	not listed
2014	8,874	$796 million	not listed
2013	8,743	$723 million	not listed
2012	8,667	$730 million	not listed
2011	9,028	$685 million	not listed
2010	8,806	$649 million	not listed
2009	9,002	$561 million	not listed

Retirement Plan for District Managers of American Family Mutual Insurance Company

Pension (defined benefit), frozenMerged

Merged. In 2015 its assets moved to the Retirement Plan for Employees of American Family Mutual Insurance Company, sponsored by American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (EIN 39-0273710, plan 001). Accounts moved with them, so that plan is the one to contact.

Plan number: 003Employer EIN 39-0273710
Participants (2014): 213
Net assets (2014): $24.4 million
Plan administrator: Retirement Plans Administrative Committee
6000 American Parkway
Madison, WI 53783
(608) 249-2111As filed for 2015
In effect since: January 1, 1973

Earlier plan names: Retirement Plan for District Managers of American Family Insurance Group.

Year by year, 2009 to 2015

Plan year	Participants	Net assets	Recordkeeper
2015	0	$0	not listed
2014	213	$24.4 million	not listed
2013	225	$20.4 million	not listed
2012	239	$19.4 million	not listed
2011	252	$19.7 million	not listed
2010	272	$21.7 million	not listed
2009	280	$20.8 million	not listed

If you had money in one of these plans

Call Empower (empower.com), which runs the American Family 401(k) Plan. With your Social Security number and the plan name, it can tell you whether you still have a balance and, if not, where it went.
Or call the plan administrator listed on the plan below ((608) 242-4100). That number was filed for 2024; ask for the benefits or retirement plan office.
If your plan was merged, your account moved with it. Follow the link on the plan to the plan it went into, and contact that one.
Still stuck? The Department of Labor's benefits advisers help for free: askebsa.dol.gov or 1-866-444-3272. Never pay anyone to find your own money.

What these numbers are

They come from the Form 5500 annual reports each plan files with the Department of Labor, as the plan filed them. A plan year is usually a calendar year.
Participants counts everyone in the plan at year end: current employees, former employees who still have a balance or a pension coming, and retirees or beneficiaries being paid.
The recordkeeper is the service provider whose Schedule C entry says it keeps the plan's records. Small plans do not file Schedule C, so some plans show none.
We cannot see anyone's account. Only the plan or its recordkeeper can tell you your balance.

Sources: U.S. Department of Labor, Form 5500 datasets and PBGC trusteed plans. How we read them.